Best price vacation rentals in Kelleys Island, OH 43438, USA • 71 Listings
Open this search on

Kelleys Island, OH 43438, USA Vacation Rentals | 

Price Comparison Results
Default SortingSettings
Open this search on
No photo yet
5.0 (15)
Conti's Cottage-Lake Views
Up to 8 guests
Airbnb$375
Vrbo$385
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (51)
Danny's "Million Dollar" View
Up to 5 guests
Airbnb$469
Vrbo$583
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
4.6 (23)
Beautiful Island Farmhouse
Up to 12 guests
Vrbo$800
Airbnb$1,000
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
4.5 (24)
Spacious Lakeside Cottage - 2 Miles to Marblehead!
Up to 12 guests
Airbnb$238
Vrbo$240
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
4.1 (12)
NEW! Marblehead Cottage w/ Fire Pit: Walk to Lake!
Up to 8 guests
Airbnb$220
Vrbo$223
Average Nightly Rate
HiChee Chrome Extension

Use our Chrome Extension. It's Free!

Get instant price-comparison savings while browsing Airbnb, Booking.com, and Vrbo!

No photo yet
3.0 (2)
Relax at our Kelleys Island Home
Up to 10 guests
Airbnb$212
Vrbo$239
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (42)
Emerald Isle Home
Up to 8 guests
Airbnb$235
Average Nightly Rate

Curious howHiCheeLogoColorfulgets its data?

ShakaCode Data logoShakaCodedata

ShakaCode scrapes. So you don't have to.

Delegate your web scraping needs to us. Get the data you need.
Focus on your primary goals.

HiCheeLogoColorfulHiChee is built and owned byShakaCode logoShakaCode

Learn more
No photo yet
5.0 (26)
Pattys Condo on the Lake - Kelleys Island, Ohio
Up to 2 guests
Airbnb$306
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (10)
A picture perfect restored original cottage located inside the gates of Lakeside
Up to 6 guests
Vrbo$240
Average Nightly Rate

Smarter Planning with Watchlists

Create your Watchlists boards and see price comparisons for multiple listings at once. You'll also get notified about price and availability changes and can share it with others.

HiChee Watchlists
No photo yet
5.0 (10)
Beautiful cottage for large families located inside the gates of Lakeside
Up to 15 guests
Vrbo$450
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (77)
Memory Manor
Up to 7 guests
Airbnb$210
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (29)
Kelleys "Island-Time" Condo
Up to 6 guests
Airbnb$250
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (34)
Quintessential Lakeside Cottage
Up to 12 guests
Airbnb$420
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (65)
Peach Street Cottage INSIDE the gates of Lakeside
Up to 6 guests
Airbnb$280
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (43)
Porch View of Lake Erie in Lakeside, Ohio
Up to 8 guests
Airbnb$215
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (42)
Wonderful Cottage 3 Blocks from the Lake/Downtown
Up to 4 guests
Airbnb$189
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (32)
Kelleys Island Getaway
Up to 8 guests
Airbnb$414
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (44)
Lakeside Love
Up to 6 guests
Airbnb$159
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (32)
Lakeside Gem
Up to 13 guests
Airbnb$225
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (50)
Cottage for Two
Up to 2 guests
Airbnb$176
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (22)
Wake on the Lake
Up to 6 guests
Airbnb$200
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (28)
Chalet on the Rock
Up to 4 guests
Airbnb$250
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (3)
Lovely Lakeside Chautauqua Cottage Rental
Up to 10 guests
Vrbo$125
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (20)
McGettaway on McGettigan
Up to 8 guests
Airbnb$314
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (13)
West Manor - Historic Gem with Modern Amenities
Up to 10 guests
Airbnb$343
Average Nightly Rate
  1. United States
  2. Ohio
  3. Kelleys Island Vacation Rental Price Comparison

Compare Airbnb vs. Booking.com vs. Vrbo prices for vacation rentals in Kelleys Island, OH 43438, USA

© 2025 HiChee.com. All Rights Reserved.

Check it before you book it! ™

Privacy PolicyTerms of Service