Best price vacation rentals in Montauk, NY 11954, USA • 150 Listings
Open this search on

Montauk, NY 11954, USA Vacation Rentals | 

Price Comparison Results
Default SortingSettings
Open this search on
No photo yet
5.0 (113)
Montauk Cottage Escape
Up to 5 guests
Vrbo$227
Airbnb$258
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (12)
Ocean View, Directly Across From Beach, Ditch Plains, Family Friendly
Up to 12 guests
Vrbo$1,071
Airbnb$1,143
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (21)
Prime East Hampton Village Location. Heated Pool. Walk To All!
Up to 10 guests
Airbnb$983
Vrbo$983
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (4)
The Blue House: Newly renovated, bright and sunny two-story home (4 BR 2.5 bath)
Up to 9 guests
Airbnb$625
Vrbo$800
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (7)
Georgia Place: Newly Renovated Kitchen, Fire pit, Close to Montauk Downs...
Up to 8 guests
Vrbo$1,049
Airbnb$1,206
Average Nightly Rate
HiChee Chrome Extension

Use our Chrome Extension. It's Free!

Get instant price-comparison savings while browsing Airbnb, Booking.com, and Vrbo!

No photo yet
5.0 (36)
Stylish and Chic Montauk Home with Pool + Backyard Oasis
Up to 6 guests
Airbnb$656
Vrbo$656
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (3)
DO NOT rent this property from Craigs List- IT IS NOT CHEAPER- IT IS A SCAM
Up to 6 guests
Airbnb$900
Vrbo$900
Average Nightly Rate

Curious howHiCheeLogoColorfulgets its data?

ShakaCode Data logoShakaCodedata

ShakaCode scrapes. So you don't have to.

Delegate your web scraping needs to us. Get the data you need.
Focus on your primary goals.

HiCheeLogoColorfulHiChee is built and owned byShakaCode logoShakaCode

Learn more
No photo yet
5.0 (18)
1 BLK FROM OCEAN; Fully Renovated; Private Beach Access in Dunes
Up to 8 guests
Airbnb$575
Vrbo$750
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (1)
Montauk 2.5 Acre property with pool- close to town, beaches and golf course
Up to 10 guests
Airbnb$1,250
Vrbo$1,450
Average Nightly Rate

Smarter Planning with Watchlists

Create your Watchlists boards and see price comparisons for multiple listings at once. You'll also get notified about price and availability changes and can share it with others.

HiChee Watchlists
No photo yet
5.0 (12)
Newly Renovated Montauk Home in Great Location on Montauk Downs Golf Course
Up to 13 guests
Vrbo$850
Airbnb$1,100
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (5)
Perfect summer rental 5 minutes from town 10 min from THE BEACH!
Up to 10 guests
Airbnb$2,500
Vrbo$2,500
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (3)
East Hampton Beauty, Newly Renovated, 4BR Contemporary all with Ensuite Baths!
Up to 10 guests
Airbnb$300
Vrbo$571
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (22)
Newly Renovated. New Finishing, Solar Heated Pool on Half Acre, With...
Up to 12 guests
Vrbo$1,272
Airbnb$1,824
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (48)
Hither Hills - Pristine Guest House on private estate; walk to beach.
Up to 4 guests
Vrbo$546
Airbnb$564
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (31)
Family Friendly, Designer 3Bd Centrally Located Home with Fenced in Yard
Up to 6 guests
Vrbo$714
Airbnb$864
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (3)
Chic, family-friendly house in the East Hampton Village Fringe
Up to 6 guests
Airbnb$995
Vrbo$995
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (70)
Sunny Private Hamptons House With Heated Pool
Up to 8 guests
Airbnb$400
Vrbo$543
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (30)
Luxurious GetAway Home With Lake View
Up to 12 guests
Vrbo$1,300
Airbnb$1,400
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (3)
Gated Grand Estate On Two Acres, Privately Landscaped
Up to 10 guests
Vrbo$2,460
Airbnb$2,869
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (17)
Pristine East Hampton Getaway! Walk to Private Beach! Huge Outdoor Shower!
Up to 8 guests
Airbnb$343
Vrbo$400
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (30)
East Hampton Getaway
Up to 12 guests
Airbnb$1,700
Vrbo$1,700
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (1)
Amagansett House On Pristine Private Beach
Up to 8 guests
Vrbo$2,500
Airbnb$4,166
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (36)
Newly renovated, private, family and pet friendly, walk to town and ocean bea...
Up to 8 guests
Vrbo$1,071
Airbnb$1,464
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (186)
Relaxing Lake Retreat
Up to 2 guests
Vrbo$198
Airbnb$221
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (82)
Luxury Family Retreat: Saltwater Pool, Peleton + Mirror, Huge Childrens PlayRoom
Up to 8 guests
Airbnb$857
Vrbo$857
Average Nightly Rate
  1. United States
  2. New York
  3. Montauk Vacation Rental Price Comparison

Compare Airbnb vs. Booking.com vs. Vrbo prices for vacation rentals in Montauk, NY 11954, USA

© 2025 HiChee.com. All Rights Reserved.

Check it before you book it! ™

Privacy PolicyTerms of Service