Best price vacation rentals in Fire Island Pines, Fire Island, NY, USA • 31 Listings
Open this search on

Fire Island Pines, Fire Island, NY, USA Vacation Rentals | 

Price Comparison Results
Default SortingSettings
Open this search on
No photo yet
5.0 (30)
CEDAR DUNES - Forest Bedroom
Up to 2 guests
Airbnb$336
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (19)
CEDAR DUNES - The Gallery Room
Up to 2 guests
Airbnb$336
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (12)
Guest Room in Renovated House in a Great Location
Up to 2 guests
Airbnb$339
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (44)
"NORTH APT." Renovated 1 Br Apt. In Great Location
Up to 4 guests
Airbnb$248
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (39)
Classic Yacht in the Fire Island Pines
Up to 4 guests
Airbnb$561
Average Nightly Rate
HiChee Chrome Extension

Use our Chrome Extension. It's Free!

Get instant price-comparison savings while browsing Airbnb, Booking.com, and Vrbo!

No photo yet
5.0 (4)
Large Heated Pool, Hot Tub, AC, Roof Deck, PINES home near Harbor!
Up to 8 guests
Vrbo$2,000
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (56)
"SOUTH APT." Renovated 1 Br Apt. In Great Location
Up to 4 guests
Airbnb$250
Average Nightly Rate

Curious howHiCheeLogoColorfulgets its data?

ShakaCode Data logoShakaCodedata

ShakaCode scrapes. So you don't have to.

Delegate your web scraping needs to us. Get the data you need.
Focus on your primary goals.

HiCheeLogoColorfulHiChee is built and owned byShakaCode logoShakaCode

Learn more
No photo yet
5.0 (11)
Fire Island Pines Harbor House
Up to 8 guests
Airbnb$866
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (13)
Stylish Private Mid Century Modern 3 bedroom house
Up to 6 guests
Airbnb$1,200
Average Nightly Rate

Smarter Planning with HiChee Trips

Create your HiChee Trips boards and see price comparisons for multiple listings at once. You'll also get notified about price and availability changes and can share it with others.

HiChee Trips
No photo yet
5.0 (27)
CEDAR DUNES - Sunset Bedroom
Up to 2 guests
Airbnb$336
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (11)
Blue Heaven B&B Guesthouse Green Room
Up to 2 guests
Airbnb$325
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (4)
Renovated House w/ Ocean Views & in Great Location
Up to 10 guests
Airbnb$1,200
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
5.0 (5)
Classic Pines Bungalow with Every Amenity
Up to 6 guests
Airbnb$1,000
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
4.7 (13)
Spotless sun-drenched pool home moments from town and beach.
Up to 8 guests
Vrbo$1,400
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
4.5 (4)
Pines Reflections Bay Front Prvt Rm 7, 1 king bed
Up to 2 guests
Airbnb$700
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
4.5 (9)
Pines Reflections Bay House, prvt room 1, 2 twins
Up to 2 guests
Airbnb$700
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
4.5 (18)
Pines Reflections Bay front rm #6, king bed
Up to 2 guests
Airbnb$700
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
4.5 (21)
Blue Heaven B&B Guest House Red Room
Up to 2 guests
Airbnb$350
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
0.0 (0)
Stunning Oceanfront Home Fire Island Pines
Up to 10 guests
Vrbo$3,250
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
0.0 (0)
Spectacular Beach House In Fire Island Pines
Up to 8 guests
Vrbo$2,100
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
0.0 (0)
PRIVATE ROOM in Industrial Designer Beach House
Up to 2 guests
Airbnb$525
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
0.0 (0)
Ocean Views!
Up to 8 guests
Airbnb$3,000
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
0.0 (0)
PRIVATE ROOM in Industrial Designer Beach House
Up to 2 guests
Airbnb$525
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
0.0 (0)
PRIVATE ROOM in Industrial Designer Beach House
Up to 2 guests
Airbnb$525
Average Nightly Rate
No photo yet
0.0 (0)
Little House In The Harbor #3
Up to 2 guests
Airbnb$400
Average Nightly Rate
  1. United States
  2. New York
  3. Fire Island Vacation Rental Price Comparison

Compare Airbnb vs. Booking.com vs. Vrbo prices for vacation rentals in Fire Island Pines, Fire Island, NY, USA

© 2025 HiChee.com. All Rights Reserved.

Check it before you book it! ™

Privacy PolicyTerms of Service